Christina Applegate's Surprising Dating Choice: Why She Chose a Rockstar Over Brad Pitt (2026)

In a candid revelation, Christina Applegate opens up about a pivotal moment in her life, explaining why she chose to leave Brad Pitt for a rockstar at the MTV Video Music Awards in 1989. Applegate, now reflecting on her journey in her memoir, 'You With The Sad Eyes', shares a story that highlights the complexities of young love and the impact of a 'sliding doors' moment.

At just 17 years old, Applegate found herself in a group of friends that included the up-and-coming actor Brad Pitt. Their relationship was purely platonic, but Applegate's curiosity led her to invite Pitt to the MTV VMAs as her date. Pitt, being the gentleman, offered to drive them to the event, ensuring Applegate's mother and best friend, Lori Allison (previously married to Johnny Depp), were safely transported.

However, the night took an unexpected turn when Applegate laid eyes on Sebastian Bach, the charismatic frontman of the band Skid Row. Bach, with his long hair and a one-year-old child, exuded an allure that captivated Applegate. In a moment of self-assurance, she decided to leave with Bach instead of Pitt, despite the latter's potential as a rising actor.

Applegate's decision caused a rift in her relationship with Pitt, who was reportedly 'mad' at her for a long time. The actor even avoided a potential fight with gang members at a petrol station, adding to his anger. Years later, Applegate's decision to choose Bach over Pitt became a topic of conversation among Pitt's movie star girlfriends, who were curious about the story behind the 'sliding doors' moment.

In a humorous twist of fate, Sebastian Bach later confirmed his involvement in this memorable night, acknowledging his former charm and popularity. Applegate's memoir provides an insightful glimpse into her life, including her career triumphs and the challenges she faced after being diagnosed with multiple sclerosis in 2021. This revelation not only showcases Applegate's honesty but also invites readers to ponder the 'what ifs' of life's pivotal moments.